A bank or fintech company wants to launch a service powered by Open Banking. The API is available, the documentation has been published, and the first requests in the test environment return successful responses. From a business perspective, the project appears ready for deployment.
The problems emerge later. Authentication flows behave differently across banks, customer consents expire, API responses are inconsistent, and integration errors are difficult to reproduce. Engineering teams spend additional weeks handling exceptions instead of developing the product.
As a result, having access to an API does not mean an Open Banking integration is production-ready. Success depends on the entire process: integration architecture, regulatory compliance, error handling, security, monitoring and operational maintenance.
How should banks and fintechs approach Open Banking implementation to reduce risk, shorten integration timelines and ensure reliable service delivery after launch?
Key takeaway: production-ready Open Banking is more than a collection of API endpoints. It requires a controlled process covering permissions, customer consent, authentication, data exchange, exception handling, testing and end-to-end integration monitoring.
Why is Open Banking implementation more complex than standard API integration?
In a conventional system integration project, an organization often controls both sides of the communication or can agree on implementation details with a single partner. Open Banking requires cooperation between entities using different systems, authentication processes and operating models.
Even when interfaces follow similar standards, implementation differences can affect how the entire service operates.
The most common challenges
- Differences between bank APIs: varying fields, statuses, limits and endpoint behavior.
- Complex authorization: redirects, authentication and session management.
- Consent lifecycle: granting, restricting, expiring and revoking access.
- Unpredictable errors: timeouts, service outages and ambiguous responses.
- Operational risk: an outage affecting one bank can disrupt the user experience of an entire application.
- Security requirements: protecting financial data and controlling access rights.
For a CTO, the main challenge is not sending an HTTP request. It is maintaining a predictable business process despite differences and failures in external API providers.
Open Banking models: AIS, PIS and participant roles
The implementation architecture depends on the service an organization intends to provide and the role it plays in the ecosystem.
AIS – Account Information Services
AIS enables an authorized provider to access specified information about a payment account with the user’s consent. It can support account aggregation, transaction history analysis and processes used to assess a customer’s financial situation.
PIS – Payment Initiation Services
PIS enables an authorized provider to initiate a payment from a user’s account. The process involves submitting a payment instruction, completing the required authentication and handling the payment status.
ASPSP and TPP
An ASPSP is an Account Servicing Payment Service Provider, such as a bank maintaining payment accounts. A TPP is a Third-Party Provider with the appropriate authorization to provide services such as AIS or PIS.
| Role / service | Main responsibility | Technology challenge |
|---|---|---|
| ASPSP | Providing appropriate interfaces for payment account access | Security, availability and core banking integration |
| AISP | Providing account information services | Consent, data quality and multi-bank integration |
| PISP | Initiating payments on behalf of users | SCA, payment statuses and uncertain operation outcomes |
These roles determine regulatory responsibilities, integration requirements and the design of the user journey.
PSD2, SCA and regulatory requirements – what should the project account for?
Within the European regulatory framework, Open Banking is closely associated with PSD2 and the Regulatory Technical Standards concerning Strong Customer Authentication and secure communication.
The applicable obligations depend on the entity’s role, service type, jurisdiction and operating model. Regulatory analysis should therefore take place before detailed architecture design.
Key areas to consider
- The regulatory status and authorization of the service provider.
- Strong Customer Authentication (SCA) requirements.
- Secure identification and communication between participants.
- Rules governing access to and use of payment account data.
- Personal data protection and appropriate operation records.
- Operational resilience and ICT risk management requirements.
Important: regulatory compliance is not achieved simply by implementing an API standard. It also involves organizational processes, authorization, security, documentation and ongoing service operations.
How should Open Banking integration architecture be designed?
The architecture should separate product logic from the specific behavior of individual banks and API providers. This allows changes to one interface without forcing a redesign of the entire application.
In Open Banking and payment integration projects, a stable integration layer is essential for handling differences between providers and exposing a consistent model of operations to the product.
Example Open Banking architecture
Banking or fintech application
Web · Mobile · Back Office · Partners
↓
Business services layer
AIS · PIS · Process Management · Data Model
↓
Open Banking Integration Layer
Adapters · Consent · Tokens · Retries · Statuses · Monitoring
↓
Bank / ASPSP APIs
Accounts · Transactions · Payment Initiation
↓
Banking systems
Core Banking · Payments · Authentication · Data
Conceptual architecture. The actual design depends on whether the organization acts as an ASPSP, a TPP or uses a third-party aggregator.
What should the integration layer provide?
- A consistent model of data and business operations.
- Adapters that isolate differences between provider APIs.
- Consent and access credential lifecycle management.
- Controlled request retries and timeout handling.
- Request traceability and end-to-end flow monitoring.
- The ability to expand integrations without modifying product logic.
API design and integration – what determines reliability?
A well-designed API integration should allow the service to evolve without becoming tightly coupled to the internal data model of a specific bank.
In practice, this requires clearly defined contracts, validation, error handling and version management.
Key design principles
- API contracts: clearly defined required fields, formats and error scenarios.
- Versioning: compatibility controls when providers introduce changes.
- Timeouts: defined maximum waiting times and application behavior.
- Retries: repeating requests only when it is safe and justified.
- Rate limiting: preventing overload and respecting partner API limits.
- Observability: correlation identifiers, metrics and logs for diagnosing problems.
It is particularly important to distinguish technical errors from business errors. An API timeout, access denial and insufficient account funds require different responses from the application.
Customer consent and access management – a critical component of Open Banking
For services that access payment account data, properly managing the scope and lifecycle of customer consent is essential.
Recording that a customer has granted consent is not enough. The system must understand which data and operations are permitted, when access expires and how to respond when permission is revoked.
The consent lifecycle
1. Process initiation
User selects a service that requires access to specific data or operations.
2. Scope definition
The system presents the access scope appropriate for the service.
3. Authorization
The user completes the required authentication and confirmation process.
4. Active access
The system accesses data or performs operations within the permitted scope.
5. Status change
Consent may expire, be revoked or require renewed authentication under applicable rules.
6. Access termination
The system blocks further operations that require authorization that is no longer valid.
It is worth distinguishing consent status from the technical status of an access token. A valid token should not be treated as sufficient authorization if the underlying permission is no longer in place.
SCA and user experience – how can banks and fintechs reduce abandonment?
Strong Customer Authentication is an important security mechanism, but it can also introduce UX friction, particularly when users are redirected between applications.
Problems occur when users fail to return after authentication, sessions expire or the application cannot reliably determine the outcome of the process.
How to improve process reliability
- Clearly explain why a redirect or authentication step is required.
- Preserve process context when the user returns to the application.
- Handle interrupted flows, timeouts and authorization refusals.
- Distinguish missing confirmation from an actual operation rejection.
- Allow safe process restarts where permitted.
- Measure conversion at each authentication stage.
From a business perspective, SCA flow reliability directly affects the number of successfully connected accounts and the effectiveness of payment initiation.
Data quality and integration consistency – why is normalization necessary?
Data retrieved from different banks can vary in structure, level of detail, naming conventions and status representation.
If the business application must handle every difference itself, code complexity and integration maintenance costs increase.
What should be normalized?
- Account identifiers and their representation.
- Amounts, currencies and date formats.
- Transaction and payment statuses.
- Counterparty information and transaction descriptions.
- Pagination and available transaction history.
- Error codes and diagnostic messages.
However, normalization should not remove important information. Access to source data, or an appropriately secured representation of it, can help diagnose discrepancies and support process audits.
Payment initiation – how to manage statuses and uncertain outcomes
In PIS, it is particularly important to distinguish between accepting a payment initiation request and actually executing the payment.
After submitting an instruction, the application may receive an intermediate status, a request for additional authentication or a technical error. None of these states automatically confirms that the payment has been completed or rejected.
Example PIS process
1. The user selects a payment and confirms its details.
2. The application submits a payment initiation request to the relevant API.
3. The user completes the required SCA process.
4. The system receives an initiation status or information about further processing.
5. The application verifies the final or currently available status using the interface’s supported mechanisms.
6. The user receives a message that accurately reflects the operation’s actual state.
Timeouts require particular care. If the response never arrives, resubmitting the instruction without checking its status may unintentionally initiate another payment.
For this reason, PIS integration should include operation identifiers, duplicate-prevention mechanisms and clear rules for handling uncertain outcomes.
Testing Open Banking – what should be verified before production?
A successful endpoint request in a sandbox is not sufficient evidence of production readiness. Testing must cover the entire user journey and system behavior under exceptional conditions.
| Testing area | What to verify | Business risk |
|---|---|---|
| API contracts | Formats, required fields, versions and error codes | Integration failures after API changes |
| Consent | Expiration, revocation and access scope changes | Unauthorized or unsuccessful access |
| SCA | Redirects, interruptions, timeouts and return to the application | Customer journey abandonment |
| AIS | Data completeness, formats and freshness | Incorrect analysis results or customer views |
| PIS | Statuses, errors, retries and uncertain outcomes | Duplicate payments or misleading status information |
| Resilience | API outages, limits and increased latency | Service disruption |
| Security | Permissions, tokens, certificates and data protection | Security and compliance breaches |
Contract, integration, end-to-end, performance and security tests are all valuable. Where the sandbox does not accurately reflect production behavior, additional test scenarios and a controlled launch are necessary.
Security and operational resilience in Open Banking integrations
Open Banking involves access to sensitive financial information and payment processes. Security must therefore be built into the architecture from the beginning rather than treated as a separate pre-production task.
Key security mechanisms
- Secure communication: appropriate TLS mechanisms, certificates and participant identification.
- Credential management: protecting and rotating tokens, keys and secrets.
- Least-privilege access: limiting permissions to required data and operations.
- Auditability: recording events without unnecessarily exposing sensitive data in logs.
- Resilience: managing timeouts, rate limits and external API dependencies.
- Monitoring: detecting errors and integration quality degradation quickly.
Institutions subject to relevant requirements should also account for digital operational resilience obligations, including ICT risk management and dependencies on third-party providers.
From sandbox to production – how to prepare for a safe launch
Moving into production is the point at which an integration project becomes an operational service. From that moment, code correctness is only one part of success. Monitoring, incident response procedures and clear maintenance ownership become equally important.
Pre-production checklist
☐ Regulatory authorization and responsibility model confirmed.
☐ Production certificates and credentials configured.
☐ AIS/PIS processes and SCA scenarios verified.
☐ Consent expiration and revocation tested.
☐ Timeout handling and partner API error management implemented.
☐ Monitoring, alerting and incident response model established.
☐ Contingency procedures and API provider contacts prepared.
☐ KPIs and post-launch integration quality evaluation defined.
Where the architecture and service model allow it, starting with a limited user group or selected integrations can help teams observe real-world behavior before scaling up.
How to measure Open Banking implementation success
The number of connected banks or available endpoints does not provide a complete picture of implementation value. What matters more is whether users can successfully complete their journeys and whether integrations operate reliably.
| KPI | What it measures | Business impact |
|---|---|---|
| Connection success rate | Percentage of successfully connected accounts | AIS journey conversion |
| SCA completion rate | Percentage of completed authentication flows | Reduced process abandonment |
| API availability | Interface availability | Service continuity |
| API latency | API response time | Faster user journeys |
| Payment initiation success rate | Percentage of successful payment initiations | PIS process effectiveness |
| Integration incident rate | Frequency of integration incidents | Operational stability |
| Time to onboard a bank | Time required to add another banking integration | Scalability of the integration model |
Metrics should be analyzed separately for individual banks, operation types and journey stages. This makes it easier to determine whether an issue originates in the user experience, internal architecture or a specific external API.
The most common Open Banking implementation mistakes
Many problems only become visible after launch because teams focused on successful API responses rather than the complete business process.
- Treating sandbox behavior as production behavior. Test environments do not always reproduce real errors, delays and authentication flows.
- Skipping a dedicated integration layer. Product logic becomes tightly coupled to each bank’s implementation.
- Incomplete consent handling. The system fails to recognize expired or revoked access correctly.
- Unsafe payment retries. A timeout triggers another instruction without verifying the original operation’s status.
- Lack of end-to-end monitoring. The team sees an API error but cannot identify which stage of the journey failed.
- Ignoring authentication UX. A technically correct process has low conversion because of redirects and unclear messages.
- No operational owner. After deployment, responsibility for incidents and partner API changes is unclear.
A successful implementation requires treating Open Banking as a product and an operational service, not a one-off integration task.
How Edge One Solutions supports banking integrations and Open Banking implementation
Open Banking implementation requires expertise in architecture, APIs, security, software development and integration testing. The priority is to combine technical correctness with the reliability of the entire business process.
Edge One Solutions supports organizations in Banking and Financial Services with digital system development, technology integrations, architecture modernization and software quality assurance.
In integration projects, stable API contracts, controlled error handling, test automation and predictable deployment processes are particularly important.
CASE STUDY
Bank Pekao – development of a digital mortgage sales channel
The project involved developing a digital mortgage sales channel, omnichannel capabilities and integrations with banking systems. It illustrates experience in developing digital services operating within a complex technology environment.
The case study concerns banking system development and integration. It does not imply that AIS or PIS services were implemented as part of this project.
Summary: Open Banking starts with APIs, but success depends on production integration
Open Banking implementation does not end when endpoints are available and sandbox tests pass.
For the service to operate reliably, teams must design the entire process, including access management, consent, SCA, data exchange, status handling, errors and monitoring.
For banks and fintechs, the greatest value comes from an architecture that enables additional integrations without rebuilding the entire product and limits the impact of external API failures on users.
For CTOs, this means shorter onboarding times for new partners, more predictable deployments and lower integration maintenance costs.
Open Banking delivers business value only when the entire journey – from customer consent to the operation outcome – is secure, measurable and resilient to failures.
Open Banking & API Integration
Your API is ready. Why is production integration still delayed?
Legacy dependencies, authorization flows, and end-to-end testing can delay an Open Banking launch. Edge One Solutions supports API development, backend integration, and production readiness to help your team manage delivery risks and technical dependencies.
